Beer traps have long been used for slug control but there is another way to trap them that doesn’t involve you sharing your precious brews (because, really, why should slugs get the good stuff?). Try this very basic yeast trap instead:

Ingredients: 

1 cup water

1 tsp sugar

1/2 tsp dry yeast

Instructions:

Throw everything into a jar and mix it together.  (You can double or triple this recipe if you are attending Slimapalooza and require lots of bait. It’s best to mix up a fresh batch each time you need it).

Raid your recycling bin for some shallow containers and sink whatever you scrounge up into your garden bed so that the tops of the containers are level with the surface of the soil. In effect, you’re creating a drop of doom/swimming pool sort of scenario.  Pour the bait mixture into the containers so that they are about 3/4 full.  Then go crack that beer and enjoy the rest of your evening.  Slugs come out at night so check your traps the next morning and dispose of the contents in the garbage.

What are your tried-and-true methods to combat slugs?

cropped-pggt-tw-1-2-2.jpg

UPDATE (25 June 2022): I’ve had a comment (see below) expressing concern that there is a possiblity of also catching beneficial insects such as ground beetles with this trap and a suggestion to make alterations to the set-up. You can definitely try the suggestion given in the comments, but ground beetles are effective crawlers/climbers and I would expect them to be able to bypass the solution. If you are worried, you could float a dry leaf or a small twig in the saucer to give the beetles something to climb onto until you rescue them the next morning.

What I should have done when I wrote this post: prefaced it with two pieces of information. #1: Handpicking (manual removal) of pests such as slugs would always be the top solution over trapping, as there are no questions of identification and no other creatures would be inadvertently harmed. #2: These traps are not meant to be set out for days, weeks, or months on end – you will put them out for one or two days to control the slug population, then remove them.

When deciding whether or not to use any methods of control for pests, you must consider whether your entire crop will be affected to the point where you will reap no benefits from it. If only a few leaves or other plant parts are affected, don’t do anything. If the damage is primarily cosmetic, don’t take any action – it’s not necessary. We need to consider the ecosystem and all of the interacting creatures within it first and foremost. Slugs need to eat, too – and in turn, they are food for birds and other creatures. The reason I put up this post was because I have been asked hundreds of times about slug control – and the gardeners who want to use it aren’t willing to go out and pick the slugs off of their plants … they want another option to deal with them.


18 responses to “No-beer slug bait recipe (yeast trap).”

  1. arlingwoman Avatar

    This is genius!

    1. Sheryl @ Flowery Prose Avatar

      It’s an easy, effective way to do the job!

    2.  Avatar
      Anonymous

      Who volunteers to monitor the garden in the dark, when these slimes creep I. Not me! I used to set out ramekins with beer and they worked but I not happy with we wasting beer on slugs. If yeast is the drug, I’m going to try your recipe in some larger plastic take-out salad dressing containers – a little smaller than a ramekin. I’m excited. Slugs have been devouring my arugula, my fave thing!! I’ll check back soon!

  2. natuurfreak2 Avatar

    Ga ik zeker eens uit proberen

    1. Sheryl @ Flowery Prose Avatar

      I hope you have success with it!

    2.  Avatar
      Anonymous

      Regarding catching beatles in slug traps, I have caught many slugs and pill bugs but not a single beatle or other insect. I wish it worked for earwigs, cause those things are as bad or worse than slugs. And I don’t think birds eat slugs, but I could be wrong. Ducks maybe, but others? In general I think slug traps are a more environmentally friendly option than poison.

  3. offtheedgegardening Avatar

    Love this! Going to try definitely give it a go.

    1. Sheryl @ Flowery Prose Avatar

      An alternative solution that works….

      1. Ian Davidson Avatar
        Ian Davidson

        Hi,
        My brother introduced me to your concoction for killing slugs etc. which I am about to try.
        One reservation I have is sinking “the tops of the containers [so they] are level with the surface of the soil” because, not only do you trap slugs and snails, you also trap all other creatures such as ground beetles and other beneficial ground-creeping creatures. Similar antidotes to yours suggest leaving a quarter inch or 5mm collar protruding above soil level thus preserving the beneficial ground-creeping insects.

        Regards
        Ian Davidson
        UK

  4. My Home Farm Avatar

    Wish I’d found your post sooner. Will definitely give this a bash.

    I introduced nematodes to our veg garden this week to fight slugs that have devastated our leafy greens. Has anyone here tried slug nematodes and have they worked for you?

    1. Ann Avatar
      Ann

      I have used nematodes successfully. Reapplication is essential. I am adding yeast bait to my arsenal.

      1. My Home Farm Avatar

        Reapplication every six weeks is essential.

    2. Malcolm Avatar
      Malcolm

      Slug nematodes are just too expensive and take time to show results and you have to use them all in one go as they don’t keep. A re application is also necessary. Beer or yeast traps are very effective and results can be seen straight away as well as the least costly method.

  5.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Does the water need to be at a certain temperature for the yeast to work?

    1. Sheryl @ Flowery Prose Avatar

      Hi! Thank you for your question! No, it doesn’t – it’s not necessary to activate the yeast with warm water. The slugs will be attracted to the enzymes in it regardless of the water temperature.

  6.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Be wary of using beer or yeast as bait. They work so well, you might attract slugs from far outside the boundaries of your garden or allotment. You are inviting them to join the feast, which can make the problem worse rather than better. If you do use these baits, don’t use them long-term.

  7. […] option is easy to make: Flowery Prose teaches that for the yeast trap, just blend a cup of water with a teaspoon of sugar and half a […]

  8.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Hi! I have used the beer trap a lot, so will save my beer from now on. One comment I would make, is that I have watched slugs climb down the container, take a drink/ sniff, and then climb out! Do they drown, or does the concoction actually kill them? I have considered putting a lid on the container and cutting slots in the side instead. This reduces the chance of the contents being diluted with rain, but it makes the escape easier.

Leave a reply to Ann Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.